PODCASTS AND MORE TO INSPIRE FOLKS IN MARKETING, MARKET RESEARCH, PLANNING & ADVERTISING
Our March ‘07 Spotlight column in ESOMAR’s Research World magazine.
Being prepared and empowered to take risks is fundamental to true innovation and progress.
A few months ago, during a podcast recording, Jem Fawcus of the innovative Firefish was asked about his attitude to risk. I naturally assumed that as an entrepreneur he would be pro risk-taking. After all, he and business partner Allison had taken big personal risks to establish their agency. But Jem surprised me with his anti-risk stance: “agencies are there to minimise client risk”.
It took me a few moments to realise he was right. But, as someone who’s an advocate of experimenting to drive innovation, which invariably involves risk, I believe that I was also right, and that risk-taking and the tolerance of mistakes should be an essential characteristic of the industry.
In the words of Sir Ken Robinson, the inspirational educator and innovator, “If you’re not prepared to be wrong, you’ll never come up with anything original.”
Managing risk
I am essentially calling for researchers to be given a license to innovate and be creative. In effect, for management in research organisations, as well as in client marketing, product and MR teams, to explicitly and sincerely tolerate risk and mistakes. Because until we find the perfect approach to addressing client issues, we should always be looking to improve through trial and error.
But that’s not to advocate risk-taking at all costs. That would be silly. Even the most ardent supporters of innovation would agree to sensible limits. In fact, when I recently emailed a prolific industry innovator a story about how someone at Google managed to lose the company $1m by mistake, something that one of the founders brushed off as a cost of their experimentation culture, my contact remarked that “luckily for them $1m is neither here nor there”.
It comes down to culture
There’s no fast track to creating a culture of innovation. It takes time. It takes persistence. It takes top level support.
“I believe a creative culture comes from combining skills that don’t normally come together and making sure that people don’t become too habitual in their working practices,” Derek Leddie, The Leading Edge
In time, though, the benefits do flow through:
“We were looking for a new way of measuring the equity of our brands. Repères took the risk of researching and developing a completely new approach. They asked for minimal development investment. Today we have undertaken 15 different projects with them and they have a licensed product that is selling well to other clients,” Mark Whiting, Moët Hennessy.
The client factor
Some naysayers among you may point to the power of clients to kill innovation. While that is true, the good news is that an increasing number of brands are picking up on the innovation vibe, including P&G, Tesco, Apple and Google, to name but a very few. Brands that not only like their agencies to exhibit similar traits but in many cases expect them to.
And the interesting thing is that as online brands proliferate and grow in influence and prominence, so does a culture of experimentation as symbolised by the term ‘beta’ (a label designed to warn users that websites/applications are not in final form and may contain errors).
As Mark Jones, managing director of travel and entertainment brand lastminute.com explains:
“One of the things that the lastminute.com brand represents is innovation. We don’t claim that everything put out there works first time…we’re not afraid of innovating and even getting it wrong amongst certainly a closed user group.”
Finance brand egg.com shares a similar culture, as profiled at last year’s Congress.
The pay-off
But can risk-taking and innovation lead to financial prosperity? Well, let’s take a look at an extreme example, Google, only eight years old, but already making around $6bn in annual profits. All driven by a culture built on systemic innovation. A culture that attracts and retains the best engineers, by giving staff 20% time to design and develop their own initiatives (most of their new products originate from this source), and ensuring that ideas are only ever internally shot down on the basis of robust, quantitative, objective data. A culture that embraces risk and mistakes, and sees them as the inconsequential cost of progress, a bit like a child trying to walk despite continually falling down.
But, you say, that’s hardly a relevant reference for the research community. Well, that’s the kicker. Google and the MR industry share the same mission: both are designed to quickly get people to the information they need. The only difference is, MR currently adds meaning.
Anyway, I’ll leave the final word to Brad Garlinghouse, a Yahoo! senior VP, who recently issued the infamous ‘Peanut Butter Manifesto’ to address his employer’s poor performance: “…the employees that we really need to stay [are] leaders, risk-takers, innovators, passionate….”
Interview begins @ around 25:49
Series:AdTalk
Series:MarketingTalk
Over 99% of the interesting stuff we come across during our sessions traversing the newsosphere (blogs etc.) don’t make it to this blog because we deliberately decided to focus on posting mainly podcasts and the odd article so as not to crowd things too much.
If you’re not reading this on the website then take a few moments to pop there. Because we’ve added a new box, top right, where we’re sharing interesting links from our cyber travels. As usual the coverage is broad, reflecting the diversity we try to cover on ResearchTalk, so this may not suit everyone.
But for those who are interested, come visit us often (list updated multiple times daily). Alternatively, given our RSS-enabled world, you can choose to subscribe to the link-blog feed here. And do let us have your feedback, good or bad.
Merci.
5mins | Produced @ AQR Trends ‘07 | More podcasts in this series
STARRING
Well, that headline certainly got your attention
But Nick doesn’t feel it’s an exaggeration, as he explains in this short chat with Chloe.
10mins | Produced @ ESOMAR Congress ‘07 | More podcasts in this series
STARRING
Geert van Kuyck of Philips is a seasoned marketing executive, having previously worked at very senior levels in Starbucks and Procter & Gamble. Here he chats with Caroline about the overwhelming need for a more authentic understanding of consumers, among both the research and marketing communities. It may surprise you to learn that he believes there’s such a big gap here (between rhetoric and reality). Have a listen to his take, and on why he regards engagement and humility as key qualities for success.
Thanks to BrainJuicer for making the video possible.
13mins | Produced @ ESOMAR Congress ‘07 | More podcasts in this series
STARRING
We were about to film the chat when Tariq mentioned his computer, with the presentation he was about to give, had crashed. He only had around an hour to recreate it and we stole about 15mins from that, but he was cool and that’s pretty impressive for a guy who founded and has built the Netvibes web 2.0 personalized home page into one of the world’s most popular blog readers and so has quite a weight of expectations on his shoulders.
This chat is probably more interesting for you web 2.0/research 2.0 folks out there. We touch on
Thanks to BrainJuicer for making the video possible.
Like Russell, we’re big fans of Peter Day’s In Business and Global Business (BBC).
In the latest Global Business, Peter chats with Professor Gary Hamel, a leading management author and thinker, about some of the themes in his new book, The Future of Management.
His key message to leaders is to shift from a culture of control to one that embraces personal creativity, posturing that this is the only path to future innovation, growth and prosperity.
The chat contains some really stirring stuff and strikes a perfect resonance with the zeitgeist (unleashing personal creativity, wisdom of crowds, bottom-up innovation, global talent etc.). We liked it so much that we spent the time to pick out some choice quotes:
“You can buy obedience and diligence and even intellect almost anywhere in the world for next to nothing.”
“We’re going to have to get people to bring to work their initiative, their creativity, their passion, and those are human capabilities that cannot be commanded. Those are gifts that people either choose to bring to work or not.”
“The existing management model was built to drive alignment, enforcement and control. What management tried to do over the last 100 years was to regularise the irregular, to drive the variety out of processes…we happen to live in a world today where it’s irregular people with irregular ideas who create all the new economic value and the wealth.”
“Organisations are less human than the people who work there. [people are inherently creative and innovative] but somehow when we get to work that adaptability, that innovation literally gets bleached out of people between 9 and 5.”
“The ability to aggregate human capability via the web, that’s not going to go away.”
Management innovation at W. L. Gore & Associates: “Every employee is free to say yes or no to any request. Most managers would have a very hard time imagining how you can get things done in an organsation where you can’t use any of your positional power (because you have none); people have to be persuaded. People are annually evaluated by 20 peers on the value they create [rather than via a hierarchy based on following strict instructions].”
Management innovation at Google: “The folks who run that they don’t primarily see themselves as the authors of strategy, they see themselves as editors of strategy…ideas bubble up.”
Pop here for the episode (hopefully it will stay archived).
Series:AdTalk Series:MarketingTalk
17mins | Related to ESOMAR Congress ‘07 | More podcasts in this series
One of the most moving presentations at this year’s Congress
covered the trials and tribulations of doing research in Afghanistan and Iraq, essentially an update to last year’s story.
Matthew Warshaw of D3 Systems Inc., one of the speakers and MD of the agency in Afghanistan (ACSOR-Surveys), gave us the video below, produced by non-profit The Asia Foundation, to share with you.
It takes us through some of the more pedestrian measures they take to get at the information and is not nearly as horrific as some of the events recounted last year.
As an aside, if you happen to meet Matthew Warshaw or his colleague Karl Feld, get them to recount some of their intriguing and fun stories from over the years. Let’s just say that Afghanistan isn’t their only experience of working in some of the more gritty or risky parts of the world
Series:Events Series:ESOMAR Series:Congress07




Just back from ESOMAR’s superbly organised and networking-friendly Berlin Congress and the first order of the day is to congratulate the award winners, pretty much all of whom have featured on RT.
So, congrats to…
We shot a bit of video while there and will endeavour to get it up over the next few weeks. It includes conversations with some of the keynotes